We’ve all done it.

Your adult child needs to borrow your car for the afternoon. A friend needs a vehicle while theirs is in the shop. A neighbor asks to borrow your truck to pick something up.

You hand over the keys without giving it much thought.

But what happens if they get into an accident while driving your car?

It’s a question most people don’t think about until they’re suddenly dealing with a damaged vehicle, insurance companies and possibly an injured driver or passenger.

And in Michigan, the answer isn’t always as simple as, “The driver has insurance, so I’m covered.”

Your Car (and Your Insurance) May Still Be Part of the Picture

One of the most important things to understand is that lending someone your vehicle doesn’t necessarily mean you’re lending them all of your insurance coverage under every circumstance.

Different portions of an auto policy cover different things, and who pays after an accident can depend on what happened, who was injured, what coverage everyone involved has and the specific terms of your policy.

That’s why I’m always hesitant when someone says, “Don’t worry, they have their own insurance.”

Their insurance may matter. But so can yours.

Permission Matters

There’s also an important distinction between someone borrowing your vehicle and someone taking it without your permission.

Michigan law can hold the owner of a vehicle responsible for injuries caused by the negligent operation of that vehicle when it is being driven with the owner’s express or implied consent.

In other words, handing someone your keys can carry responsibilities beyond simply trusting them to bring the car back with a full tank of gas.

What About Damage to Your Car?

Whether damage to your own vehicle is covered will depend in part on the physical damage coverage you’ve purchased.

As I’ve discussed before, collision coverage is optional in Michigan, and the type of collision coverage you carry matters. Your deductible and the circumstances of the accident can affect what your insurance company pays.

If you don’t carry collision coverage, don’t assume someone else’s insurance will automatically pay to repair your vehicle.

What If Someone Is Injured?

This is where Michigan’s No-Fault system can become considerably more complicated.

Personal Injury Protection, or PIP, helps pay allowable expenses for injuries resulting from an automobile accident, subject to the coverage selected. But determining which insurer is responsible for an injured person’s benefits can depend on that person’s own insurance coverage and household situation, among other factors.

That’s one reason I don’t like giving people a blanket answer about what will happen after an accident involving a borrowed car.

The details matter.

Be Especially Careful About Regular Drivers

There’s a big difference between letting a friend borrow your car once and having someone regularly drive a vehicle that’s insured in your name.

If your college-age child, adult child, roommate or another member of your household regularly drives your vehicle, don’t simply assume your existing policy handles that arrangement the way you think it does.

Make sure your insurance company knows who regularly operates the vehicles in your household and confirm how they’re covered.

And if someone is specifically listed as an excluded driver on your policy, handing that person the keys can create a very serious coverage problem.

Before You Hand Over the Keys

I’m certainly not suggesting that you should never let anyone borrow your car. I lend things to family and friends just like everyone else.

But before someone regularly uses your vehicle, or before you lend it to someone when you’re unsure about your coverage, it’s worth asking a few questions.

Does this person have a valid driver’s license? Are they specifically excluded from my policy? Does my insurer need to know they’re regularly driving the vehicle? What collision coverage do I have? What are my liability limits?

Those are much easier questions to answer while the car is sitting safely in your driveway than after an accident.

One More Reason to Understand Your Policy

After more than 30 years of handling automobile accident cases, one lesson comes up again and again: the worst time to discover what your insurance policy actually covers is after something has happened.

If someone in your household regularly drives your car, or you simply aren’t sure what your policy provides when someone else is behind the wheel, call your insurance agent and ask.

And as always, my standing offer applies. If you’d like another set of eyes on your auto insurance policy, I’m happy to review it with you at no charge.

Sometimes a few minutes spent asking questions today can prevent a very unpleasant surprise tomorrow.

Get Important Information and Legal Tips Straight To Your Inbox!